[Kari]

It's the good ole' 'Which companion do you prefer' thread! Oh boy...

Now I would say I'm a closet Martha fan, but honestly... I feel sorry for her in some ways. And I think I like her because I also love Freema; she had a hard act to follow from Billie Piper and the writers did her NO favors at all. Pisses me off xD Damn you RTD!

I think my favorite companion ever is Amy Pond...

BUT... my favorite companion for Ten would be.... *drumroll* Mr. Captain Jack Harkness xD Don't tell me any different :3 Girls cause so much drama yanno? :P At least CJ can save himself...

But all in all... all companions break the Doctor's heart...

[macduff]

I would have to say Rose or Captain Jack. However I love each of the companions in their own way because they meant different things to 10 and he needed everyone of them :)

[The Doctor]

Definitely Captain Jack. But I will also say Wilfred Mott if he counts.

[Kelsey]

I appreciate all of the companions in their own unique ways, but I really think Donna or Amy are my favorites right now. I'm like Kari, I feel sorry for Martha because honestly, she had to put up with a crap script at times, but I think she's my least. I still like her though, I just think the other ones outshined her :(

Oh and of course Captain Jack XD

[The Doctor]

If I can revise my decisions, I think my favorite companion after some proper thinking is Rory. Don't ask me why :P

[Kelsey]

AHH Good thought, I absolutely ADORE Rory, I didn't know if he could be included since he technically wasn't there the full time... Who knows, I hope he's signed on for next season *crosses fingers*

[Loren]

Team Rose.
Martha made/makes me want to kick puppies, she annoyed/annoys me to no end.
Martha needs to go somewhere.

[Donna Torchwood]

Favorite companion for Ten?
Here's my all time listings for companions and the Great #10:

Martha Jones
Why?
Because she saved his life more than anyone else, and although she was RTD's "unrequited love" you gotta hand it to someone who walked the frakkin' earth for the Doctor.
(Really disappointed in the novel as there's diddly squat about America)
Then:
Donna Noble
Because she didn't put up with his b.s. well she did but in little bites. And she could actually talk to him and he listened.
and Finally (yes there's an end nearing)
Capt. Jack Harkness
Because Jack created Torchwood in the Doctor's honor and he would always have the Doctor's back no matter what face he wore/wears.

[Kari]

Donna Torchwood, on 22 June 2010 - 01:45 PM, said:

Favorite companion for Ten?
Here's my all time listings for companions and the Great #10:

Martha Jones
Why?
Because she saved his life more than anyone else, and although she was RTD's "unrequited love" you gotta hand it to someone who walked the frakkin' earth for the Doctor.
(Really disappointed in the novel as there's diddly squat about America)
Then:
Donna Noble
Because she didn't put up with his b.s. well she did but in little bites. And she could actually talk to him and he listened.
and Finally (yes there's an end nearing)
Capt. Jack Harkness
Because Jack created Torchwood in the Doctor's honor and he would always have the Doctor's back no matter what face he wore/wears.

I really love your points. You = made of win xD

Martha DID walk the Earth for him, I don't even know if I could do that for any man/alien/thing xD

[Kelsey]

Why was I just overcome to sing CAUSE I WILL WALK 500 HUNDRED MILES, AND I WOULD WALK 500 HUNDRED MORE JUST TO BE THE MAN WHO WALKED A THOUSAND MILES TO FALL DOWN AT YOUR DOOR really loudly to David? I'd walk a thousand miles. to fall down. At David's door.

Maybe. I'd probably give up at mile 2. Knowing me.

[Donna Torchwood]

Kelsey, on 23 June 2010 - 11:31 AM, said:

Why was I just overcome to sing CAUSE I WILL WALK 500 HUNDRED MILES, AND I WOULD WALK 500 HUNDRED MORE JUST TO BE THE MAN WHO WALKED A THOUSAND MILES TO FALL DOWN AT YOUR DOOR really loudly to David? I'd walk a thousand miles. to fall down. At David's door.

Maybe. I'd probably give up at mile 2. Knowing me.

Walking of course in Converse Trainers!

[Donna Torchwood]

Loren, on 22 June 2010 - 02:57 PM, said:

Team Rose.
Martha made/makes me want to kick puppies, she annoyed/annoys me to no end.
Martha needs to go somewhere.

To each her own. I feel the same way about Rose. I do. But the Doctor loved her and I can't fault him for that.

[Kelsey]

It's sort of like picking your favorite Doctor. I've seen some people get ruthless about it, but it all comes down to some people just have that "charm" to certain people. Like Rose's mom? Made me want to scratch my nails against a chalkboard. It just is what it is for some people.

[Kari]

Exactly, and sometimes I'm too fickle and love them all to choose or just don't want to choose :) But I hate it when fans are like "No, [so and so] is the best]" and they're "right". I mean everyone has an opinion

[Ari]

For me it will be Rory and Donna, both of them, simply brilliant

[Kelsey]

I think they needed more male companions anyways. No matter how who they choose, there's always the under current "love" relationship at question. It's getting tiring. Choose a male and be different!